Worsening health helped drive a rise in youth disengagement

A rise in the number of young people in the United Kingdom who are not in work, education or training was largely driven by worsening mental and physical health, according to a UCL-led study published in BMC Global and Public Health.

The researchers examined survey responses from more than 15,000 people aged 16 to 24 who took part in the UK Household Longitudinal Study between 2009 and 2023. Their analysis compared the 2014–18 period with 2019–23 and found that a growing share of young people reporting a health problem was a significant factor in explaining the increased proportion who were not in work, education or training.

People in this group are commonly described as NEETs, a term used for those who are neither employed nor enrolled in education or training. The label is widely used in labour-market and social-policy discussions, but the study’s findings point toward health as a central part of the explanation for recent increases rather than treating disengagement solely as an employment or education issue.

The research does not argue that work and education policy is unimportant. Instead, it suggests that policies focused only on the labour market are unlikely to fully address the problem if the underlying decline in young people’s health is left untreated.

The study challenges a common interpretation

One of the most consequential findings concerns what the researchers call the “penalty” of having a health problem: the likelihood that a young person with a health problem is out of work, education or training.

That penalty remained broadly similar in the two periods studied. In other words, the analysis did not find that a young person with a health problem had become more likely to be NEET than a decade earlier. The larger change was the number of young people experiencing health problems in the first place.

Lead author Dr. Jacques Wels of UCL’s Unit for Lifelong Health and Ageing said the results challenge the idea that today’s young people with health issues are simply less able or willing to participate than previous cohorts. The study instead indicates that young people after 2019 were not more fragile; they were more likely to be unwell.

That distinction matters for how the issue is understood. If the problem were primarily a changing response to ill health, policy might focus heavily on incentives, expectations or routes back into work and education. If the main driver is a worsening health profile across the population of young people, prevention, early support and access to care become much more central.

Nearly a million young people were estimated to be NEET

The study arrives amid a high national estimate for youth disengagement. Between April and June of the year cited in the report, an estimated 981,000 UK residents aged 16 to 24 were not in work, education or training. That equates to about one in eight people in the age group.

Such figures can be discussed as an economic challenge because periods outside work and education can affect earnings, skills and opportunities. But the UCL findings add a health dimension that is easy to miss in broad statistics. A young person’s absence from work or study may be connected to a physical or mental health condition, rather than to a straightforward lack of motivation or an inability to find an available place.

The source material does not detail every type of health problem captured by the survey data, nor does it assign a single cause for the increase in ill health. The research does, however, identify the rise in reported health problems as a significant explanatory factor in the changing NEET rate across the periods examined.

That evidence also cautions against treating young people as a uniform group. A broad NEET figure combines people with different circumstances, needs and routes back into participation. Policies designed around a single explanation may therefore miss those whose main barrier is obtaining timely and effective healthcare.

Implications for policy and support

Senior author Professor Praveetha Patalay, also of UCL’s Unit for Lifelong Health and Ageing and the Centre for Longitudinal Studies, said the findings suggest that labour-market interventions will not fully solve the problem unless they are paired with efforts to reverse the deterioration in young people’s health.

The researchers point specifically to greater investment in mental-health prevention, earlier intervention and improved access to treatment. These measures are relevant because they aim to reduce or respond to health problems before they become entrenched barriers to education, training or employment.

Early intervention can be particularly important during the transition from adolescence into adult life, when people may be moving between school, higher education, training, family support and the labour market. A gap in care or support during that period can have consequences that are reflected later in participation statistics.

The study also offers a useful framing for employers, educators and policymakers. Interventions that improve job matching, training places or engagement may still assist many young people. Yet the evidence suggests they need to sit alongside health support rather than substitute for it. A programme that assumes every participant is ready to work or study may be poorly matched to those dealing with untreated or poorly supported health problems.

A health and participation challenge

The UCL-led analysis does not reduce the complex issue of youth disengagement to one cause. It identifies a measurable shift: from 2014–18 to 2019–23, a larger prevalence of health problems among young people significantly contributed to the rise in the share who were NEET, while the disadvantage associated with having a health problem did not materially worsen.

That finding reframes an often politicized debate. It suggests the question is not simply why more young people are outside work, education and training, but why more are experiencing health problems that can limit their ability to take part.

Addressing that question will require attention to the conditions that support health as well as to the systems that support participation. The study’s core conclusion is direct: efforts to lower youth NEET rates must be connected to meaningful investment in preventing ill health, intervening earlier and improving access to treatment.

Key points

  • The study analyzed data from more than 15,000 UK residents aged 16 to 24 between 2009 and 2023.
  • An increase in young people reporting health problems significantly helped explain a higher NEET rate after 2019.
  • The likelihood of being NEET among young people with health problems stayed similar across the compared periods.
  • The researchers call for prevention, earlier intervention and better access to treatment alongside labour-market measures.

This article is based on reporting by Phys.org. Read the original article.

Originally published on phys.org